- Dish Wireless reached a $525 million settlement with American Tower
- Progress is being made with other parties, but Crown Castle is still waiting for a call
- Various parties are looking at the Dish gear that still sits on Crown Castle towers, according to Crown CEO Christian Hillabrant
Dish Wireless has reached a $525 million settlement with American Tower and is close to settling with others, but Crown Castle is still waiting in the wings.
During a bankruptcy court hearing Wednesday, Dish Wireless said the $525 million settlement figure will come from the $2.4 billion trust established by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC).
Dish parent EchoStar was required to set up the fund to win FCC approval for its spectrum sales to AT&T and SpaceX. The FCC still needs to approve Dish’s agreement with American Tower before the funds are allocated.
Matt Linder, an attorney at White & Case who is representing Dish, told U.S. Bankruptcy Court Judge Christopher Lopez that at the beginning of the bankruptcy court process, Dish Wireless was like the new kid at school who didn’t have many friends.
Over time, “the other kids have started to come around, so to speak, and we’re already starting to sit together in class,” he said.
That’s reflected in the settlements. Dish has made significant progress with other large creditors, including SBA Communications, Lumos and Charter Communications.
Crown Castle: No one is calling us
But it’s a much different situation for Crown Castle. Kyle Kimpler, an attorney representing the tower company, said that over the last eight weeks Crown Castle has not received a single proposal or had a single call with the debtors or EchoStar.
Picking up on Linder’s school room analogy, Kimpler said that Crown Castle is “very much the kid at the lunchroom table sitting by themselves, and I think that is by design.”
Linder said that after allocating money for small claims under $100,000 and $545 million for larger claims outside of the big three tower companies, what’s left is about $1.5 billion in the trust for Crown Castle and others that don’t reach a settlement with Dish.
Crown Castle says Dish owes it about $3.5 billion – more than double what’s in that remaining pot.
What is Crown Castle going to do with Dish’s old gear?
Crown Castle’s claim isn’t the only thing it has riding on Dish. Speaking at a Morgan Stanley investor conference on Wednesday, Crown Castle President and CEO Christian Hillabrant was asked how practical it would be for a new operator – like, maybe SpaceX – to use Dish’s abandoned equipment on its towers.
Hillabrant said Crown Castle has been very pleased with the interest that multiple parties have expressed about using the Dish gear. He pointed out the time and effort that would be saved by using equipment that’s already installed versus going through all the hoops to locate and negotiate new leases.
If getting to market quickly is an imperative for a new competitor, using the Dish equipment already sitting on structures could shave off between one to two years of go-to-market time. Crown currently has Dish equipment on 12,000 of its towers.
Whether a customer could use the existing equipment would depend on their spectrum portfolio and deployment plans. “But it could just as easily be swapped out very quickly with a simple electrical permit that would significantly speed the time to market for somebody looking at that,” he said.
Read more stories about the Dish bankruptcy on Fierce Network:
EchoStar’s Dish DBS emerges from bankruptcy – wireless still in limbo
Dish’s bankruptcy exposes the messy aftermath of its 5G gamble
EchoStar cites ‘force majeure’ as Dish 5G contractors cry foul