- Elon Musk calls indoor coverage the "missing piece of the puzzle" for Starlink Mobile
- The solution? Small ground stations, possibly bundled with Starlink terminals, that sit on rooftops for coverage in densely populated areas
- "I don't think this means AT&T or Verizon or others go out of business," Musk said, though they may lose some revenue
Alright. Alright. Alright. We’re back to micro cell towers being part of the SpaceX plan that will bring Elon Musk’s cell phone network plans down to Earth. If this leaves you dazed and confused, join the party. Let’s just roll with it…
Seriously though, Musk shared some of his current thinking about how Starlink Mobile will expand into the mobile carrier business during an appearance at the New York Times Dealbook Summit on Wednesday.
Musk said SpaceX is looking to produce “micro cell towers” as soon as next year to help it offer nationwide coverage. PCMag already wrote about it here.
This seems to jibe with comments Musk and SpaceX President Gwynne Shotwell made during an earnings call in August. However, during the earnings call in October, she dropped “towers” into the conversation, which came after a Bloomberg report that said SpaceX was eyeing 80,000 cell phone towers for its network.
A lot more credibility entered the picture earlier this month when Qualcomm announced that it will be supplying its Dragonwing QRU100 and QDU100 platforms and commercial-grade Layer 1 software to SpaceX for deployment at tens of thousands of sites – all macro sites, not small cells.
The macro tower story sounds a lot more believable if SpaceX/Starlink Mobile wants to compete with the Big 3 U.S. wireless carriers for the hearts and minds of cell phone consumers. However, that’s not entirely clear, either – Musk talks about a far bigger target than cell phone customers.
But anyway. Let’s not be too judgy. No one underestimates the power of Elon Musk and what he could do to upend the wireless industry in a very big way.
Indoor coverage problem solved?
At the DealBook event, Musk said they’ve got a plan that broadly enables “ubiquitous access on Earth,” including via cell phone. They’ll be launching the Starlink direct-to-cell (D2C) Version 2 satellite constellation starting next year, which will have something like 40x the bandwidth of the current D2C system.
“But there is a missing piece of the puzzle here, which is that if you’re indoors, especially if you have a metal roof, that blocks the signal from space. So we need something that’s terrestrial that addresses situations where people are, you know, in a building with a thick roof essentially,” he said.
That’s where the 800 MHz spectrum they’re buying from Grain Management comes into play, “where we can establish what I call micro ground stations … and have a network of very small ground stations that are maybe bundled together with Starlink terminals. That’s one of the approaches,” he said.
In other words, “instead of having these big cell towers all over the place, having a whole bunch of sort of micro cell sites that are scattered throughout densely populated areas… We have a design for this and it’s going into production, I think, next year,” he said, describing it as something “quite revolutionary” that goes on a roof, similar to a Starlink dish.
“It addresses the problem of reaching people who are in a building,” he said. “By the way, I don’t think this means AT&T or Verizon or others go out of business or anything. Maybe they’ll lose some revenue here, but I actually think that the demand for bandwidth will be tremendous in the future and that bandwidth will be driven primarily by super intelligence and robots.”
In addition, “they’re going to need a lot more bandwidth than humans because while humans can speak at maybe 100 bits per second at a peak rate, the computers can do it at a trillion bits per second. That means you’re really going to want several orders of magnitude more bandwidth” to service the super intelligence and vast number of robots that will exist in the future, he said.
Story shifts from time to time
Micro, macro or some hybrid of both? At one point, it appeared that SpaceX was going to enter the mobile phone industry with a network primarily composed of satellites and possibly femtocells using spectrum it bought from EchoStar. Then came the 800 MHz spectrum – but still far less spectrum than any of the Big 3 U.S. wireless operators have.
All the while, the CEOs at the Big 3 say they're not interested in doing an MVNO deal with SpaceX/Starlink Mobile. Instead, they're trying to encourage more competition in the D2C – aka direct-to-device (D2D) – ecosystem through a joint venture.
Plans for a special session?
Musk said during the SpaceX earnings call last month that Starlink Mobile’s game plan is too big to try to describe during the typical earnings call and suggested they might hold a special event to walk everyone through the process.
Sounds like a good idea – and be sure to invite the trade press too, OK?
Read more about SpaceX’s plans to upend the mobile industry on Fierce Network:
SpaceX’s nationwide terrestrial 5G plans get real as Qualcomm signs on
Do SpaceX’s ‘missing pieces’ carry a Dish logo on them?
SpaceX helps give towers new lease on life
SpaceX might sign deals for 80,000 towers to build mobile network, or is it bluffing?
Elon Musk: Starlink Mobile’s game plan too big for an earnings call